The Curse of the Forbidden Chant 101
But just under the surface, a controversy was brewing. In the build-up to the biggest game of the
year against the dreaded Toronto Argonauts, Mr. Young let it be known that he was personally repulsed
by the hallowed chant "Argos Suck!", notwithstanding its special place in the hearts of thousands of
Hamiltonians. Subsequently, the Tiger-Cats could only manage to squeak out a disappointing 30-30
tie in the Labour Day Classic. Yet, no one really thought much of this slight stumble on
the road to "excellence and beyond." However, as Mr. Young continued to pillory Hamilton's
beloved chant through the remainder of the season, the Tiger-Cats sunk to third place in the
standings and lost out on a home playoff game.
But, little did the good people of Hamilton know that the worst was yet to come. A few days
after the playoff loss, in a missive that would come to be known as "The Edict of the Forbidden Chant",
Mr. Young announced on the team's website that the beloved cheer "Argos Suck!" would now be
officially banned by the Tiger-Cat franchise. "Argos Suck!" merchandise would be pulled
from the organization's retail stores. The team's official discussion forum was rigged so
as to automatically censor the offending words, lest any fan dare attempt to put them in writing.
Despite this counter-offensive, the pleas of the people of Hamilton fell on deaf ears,
and Bob Young refused to revoke the Edict of the Forbidden Chant. Sure enough, as the
2005 season began, the Tiger-Cats stumbled to an 0-6 start. Things then went from bad
to worse, and the once-proud Hamilton franchise whimpered to a 5-13 finish.
After such an unexpected disaster, many were now convinced that The Edict of the Forbidden Chant
had placed a curse on the franchise. This was again communicated to Mr. Young, but to no avail.
Instead, Mr. Young imported one of the CFL's most highly-touted quarterbacks, Jason Maas, for
the 2006 season, thinking that this would show the good people of Hamilton that there is no such thing as a curse.
Although most were convinced that a sports curse had indeed descended on the franchise as a
result of The Edict of the Forbidden Chant, still Mr. Young ignored the pleas of his fan
base. As the "caretakers" of the now-forbidden chant and its accompanying history and heritage,
the board of directors at www.argos-suck.com attempted to showcase their social consciousness
in a series of charitable actions designed to allay Mr. Young's unfounded fears about the moral
uprightness of the sacred phrase.
After this rebuff, the woes continued. The Argos slaughtered the Tiger-Cats on
Labour Day. Jason Maas inexplicably put up the worst numbers of his entire career,
and Hamilton wound up the season with a 4-14 record. The team had regressed even
further from the debacle of 2005. It was impossible at this point even for the skeptics
to ignore the curse brought on by the Edict of the Forbidden Chant.
JOIN THE FIGHT!! RELEASE THE CURSE!!
After flirting with insolvency throughout the 1990s, the Hamilton Tiger-Cats finally hit
rock bottom in 2003, putting up a 1-17 record that basically ensured the team's demise.
However, just as all seemed lost, a rumour began circulating through the streets of Hamilton
that a "Mr. X" would ride in at the eleventh hour and save the storied franchise.
Incredibly, the rumour was correct, and "Mr. X" turned out to be Mr. Robert Young, a
Hamilton expatriate-turned-king of the American dot com revolution.
Ticat fortunes turned abruptly around in Young's freshman year. For the first time in decades,
the stands at Ivor Wynne Stadium were packed with fans. Hamiltonians were awestruck by the new paint
and the flowers in the washrooms. On the brink of extinction only months before, football
was suddenly alive and well in Hamilton. And, in the feel-good story of the year, the 2004
Tiger-Cats went 9-8-1 and qualified for the playoffs under former Canadian university
coach Greg Marshall, who would go on to win CFL Coach of the Year honours. Everything that
Bob Young touched was turning to (black and) gold.
No matter though. The people of Hamilton were simply content to be in the running for the Grey Cup
once more. But, as the anti-chant comments continued to emanate from the highest echelons of the
Tiger-Cat organization, Hamilton's most sacred team came apart in the playoffs, taking almost
200 yards of penalties on the way to a stunning 24-6 semi-final loss to the dreaded Argos in
which they could not even manage a touchdown. Worse still, this allowed the Toronto team to
back into the Grey Cup, where they upset the heavily-favoured B.C. Lions, leaving Hamilton
and all of Canada utterly devastated. It was almost as if all the anti-chant rhetoric had
brought down a sports curse upon the Tiger-Cats.
Renouncing the chant became a condition of employment for Tiger-Cat players and employees
alike. Worst of all however, Mr. Young set his sights on eliminating the chant among
everyday Hamiltonians by offering $1,000 for anyone who could come up with a more saccharine replacement cheer.
To their everlasting credit, the good people of Hamilton refused to take the bait. Instead,
the fans attempted to show Mr. Young the error of his ways by demonstrating that the beloved
chant was ingrained in the social fabric of Hamilton's history and culture. Toronto fans even
pleaded with Mr. Young not to mess with this storied tradition, while none other than the sage
Michael "Pinball" Clemons publicly stated that the "Argos Suck!" chant was an integral part of
the Hamilton-Toronto rivalry.
But, things continued to go downhill. Firstly, accusations of collusion and tampering in
the Jason Maas deal sullied Mr. Young's reputation, as well as the reputation of the CFL. T
hen, the firing of some Hamilton Tiger-Cat cheerleaders after an appearance on the Howard Stern
show made a further mockery of Young's attempt to stake out the moral high ground with his anti-chant
philosophy. The revamped Tiger-Cats opened the 2006 season with a terrible 0-4 start, which led to the
firing of coach Greg Marshall. Formerly the embodiment of Mr. Young's pre-Edict success, Marshall and all
that he represented now became just one more casualty of the curse.
Sympathizers within the Tiger-Cat organization bravely broke protocol and promoted these
efforts on the team's website, and a new spirit of détente emerged. It seemed that the Edict,
and therefore the curse, was about to be lifted, just in time for the 2006 Labour Day Classic.
However, Mr. Young pronounced the campaign a cynical ploy, denigrated the hopeful citizens of
the Forbidden Demographic as "reprehensible at best", and let it be known that the Edict would
remain in force.
2007, we were told, would be different. Two-time CFL Coach of the Year Charlie Taaffe was brought
in to right the ship. The Forbidden Demographic pleaded with Bob Young to pre-emptively release
the curse, so as to not drag Coach Taaffe into its vortex, but to no avail. Instead, Young
proudly boasted that "your Curse argument" will be exposed as nonsense "once Charlie has
this team winning." But it quickly became clear that the curse was still in play, as the
Cats came out to an 0-5 start. In desperation, the Dear Leader of the Forbidden Demographic
was flown in from an undisclosed location in Western Canada
in a bid to forestall the curse.
An impromptu conference was arranged between Ticats General Manager Marcel Desjardins and
the Dear Leader, and lo and behold, on 3 August 2007, the Tiger-Cats pulled out their first
victory of the season.
With the season still salvageable, never was there a better time to renounce The Edict of the Forbidden Chant.
However, Mr. Young refused to budge. And so it followed that, instead of building on the victory,
the Cats sank into another losing streak that ended any realistic expectation of a playoff appearance,
with over two months of the season still to play. Even worse, the franchise is currently on track to
plummet to a 3-15 season, a result even worse than the dismal years 2006 and 2005. Attendance has dropped
to its lowest levels of the Bob Young era. Initially little more than an annoyance, the curse has now
become a literal threat to the very existence of the Hamilton Tiger-Cats.
Therefore, after three long years, the Forbidden Website and allied parties have
taken it upon themselves to put an end to the curse once and for all. The Edict of the
Forbidden Chant has affected not only Hamilton, but has also eroded the Argo-Ticat rivalry that
is so vital to the CFL. Furthermore, league parity has also been rent asunder by the curse.
By threatening the CFL in this fashion, it is not just football, but the very fabric of Canadian
society that has been put in grave danger. Our last hope is that on "Release the Curse" Night,
live at the Legendary Horseshoe Tavern, CFL fans across the country will unite in an effort to set
things right. Please stay tuned for more updates.